Too Ka Man (杜家文) "Dishonest, Evasive, Recklessly Irresponsible and Wholly Unreliable" - Says Court - [2019] HKDC 971
Too Ka Man (杜家文) "Dishonest, Evasive, Recklessly Irresponsible and Wholly Unreliable" - Says Court - [2019] HKDC 971 CHAN CHAM PONG CEDRIC (陳湛邦) v TOO KA MAN (杜家文) & MANSON WATER AND ELECTRIC COMPANY LIMITED (文信水電裝修工程有限公司) - [2019] HKDC 971 - Date of Judgment - 26 July 2019 https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/ju_frame.jsp?DIS=123352&currpage=T The Evidence of D1 (the 3rd Witness) 15. The 3rd witness was D1. He struck me as a dishonest, evasive, recklessly irresponsible and wholly unreliable witness. I find the following non-exhaustive features in D1’s evidence wholly unacceptable: - (1) D1’s witness statement, dated 13 December 2017, was professionally prepared with the assistance of lawyers. D1 signed a statement of truth verifying its contents as true. During D1’s examination-in-chief, D1 corrected just one word in this witness statement and confirmed the rest of its contents as true. When cross-examine...